Why reference $? explicitly

shshell

A lot of sh code looks like:

$cmd
if [ $? = 0 ]; then $cmd2; fi

Instead of:

if $cmd; then $cmd2; fi

I have typically assumed that people use the former simply because they are unaware that the syntax of the latter is valid, but I'm wondering if there is another reason (although the only possibility that comes to mind is portability). Is there any reason to prefer explicitly referencing ${?}?.

Best Solution

You have to reference $? if you actually want to use the error code for something (logging, handling expected errors, etc.). For the particular scenario that you mention, the second if construct is both clearer and shorter, and I see no reason not to use it.

Related Solutions

Bash – Why can’t I change directories using “cd” in a script

Shell scripts are run inside a subshell, and each subshell has its own concept of what the current directory is. The cd succeeds, but as soon as the subshell exits, you're back in the interactive shell and nothing ever changed there.

One way to get around this is to use an alias instead:

alias proj="cd /home/tree/projects/java"

Python – Why do people write #!/usr/bin/env python on the first line of a Python script

If you have several versions of Python installed, /usr/bin/env will ensure the interpreter used is the first one on your environment's $PATH. The alternative would be to hardcode something like #!/usr/bin/python; that's ok, but less flexible.

In Unix, an executable file that's meant to be interpreted can indicate what interpreter to use by having a #! at the start of the first line, followed by the interpreter (and any flags it may need).

If you're talking about other platforms, of course, this rule does not apply (but that "shebang line" does no harm, and will help if you ever copy that script to a platform with a Unix base, such as Linux, Mac, etc).

Best Solution

Related Solutions

Bash – Why can’t I change directories using “cd” in a script

Python – Why do people write #!/usr/bin/env python on the first line of a Python script

Related Question